July 01, 2004

Pitfalls of Virtual Property

"The debate over who owns what in persistent-world games got a bit more knotty recently when online gaming consultancy The Themis Group released a white paper written by one of its advisory board members, Richard Bartle. Bartle is an Essex University principal fellow and author of the 1993 book, Designing Virtual Worlds. He has become one of the most visible commentators on the subject of "ownership" of virtual-world property. For anyone who has kept abreast of the conversation, the complications come as no surprise. As Dibbell wrote recently in his blog, "The games we choose for our amusement are becoming so complex, so involving, that the line between gameplay and career, between gameworld and society, begins to blur." According to Bartle, the blurring will get worse before it gets better."

Gamespot news article

Richard Bartle's white paper (pdf)

Posted by kurt at July 1, 2004 11:25 AM

Comments

Not only is property an issue, but, perhaps more consequentially, the kinds of protection that civil law offers over the virtual inhabitants of virtual worlds. A Supreme Court ruling in 2002 (CNN's nugget: http://www.cnn.com/2002/LAW/04/16/scotus.virtual.child.porn/?related and the full Court syllabus: http://supct.law.cornell.edu/supct/html/00-795.ZS.htmlraised this issue. The Atty Gen'l wanted to establish child protection laws to "real" as well as "virtual" children. The Court struck down a law that made it illegal to own or distribute movies or images of virtual children. During the time in which the law was in effect (from 1996 until 2002), virtual children had the same protection under federal law as real children, which is remarkable despite the fact that the Court struck the law down. One can look at this as a 6 year "test" of how to live within virtual worlds and live with their virtual inhabitants.

Posted by: jbleecker at July 2, 2004 08:49 AM

Post a comment

Thanks for signing in, . Now you can comment. (sign out)

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)


Remember me?


Faceroll

Erin Dinehart
2nd Year
Nov 18 @ 5:04AM

Anne Balsamo
Faculty
Nov 16 @ 9:39AM

Perry Hoberman
Faculty
Nov 11 @ 2:04PM

Michael Naimark
Faculty
Nov 8 @ 1:03PM

Mark Bolas
Faculty
Nov 1 @ 5:55PM

Scott Fisher
Director
Oct 26 @ 8:38PM

Marientina Gotsis
Staff
Oct 23 @ 11:22AM

Peggy Weil
Faculty
Oct 15 @ 1:51PM

Jessica Rosenblatt
1st Year
Oct 8 @ 3:53PM

Peter Brinson
Faculty
Oct 7 @ 1:06PM

Tracy Fullerton
Faculty
Oct 6 @ 12:17PM

Susana Ruiz
3rd Year
Oct 5 @ 12:26PM

Michael Steffen
2nd Year
Oct 2 @ 1:16PM

Vincent Diamante
1st Year
Sep 25 @ 9:49PM

Noah Keating
1st Year
Sep 25 @ 10:28AM

Justin Hall
1st Year
Sep 11 @ 6:18PM

Jenova Chen
2nd Year
Aug 12 @ 12:48AM

Victoria Moran
1st Year
Apr 17 @ 11:51AM

Will Carter
3rd Year
Mar 3 @ 3:35PM

Kellee Santiago
2nd Year
Feb 16 @ 4:22PM

Chris Swain
Faculty
Feb 4 @ 6:44PM

Jen Stein
Staff
Jan 30 @ 1:10PM

Todd Furmanski
3rd Year
Dec 16 @ 12:13PM

Yuechuan Ke
1st Year
Sep 7 @ 5:15PM

Brad Newman
2nd Year
Mar 6 @ 4:39PM

Mihai Peteu
1st Year
Sep 18 @ 10:09AM

Aaron Meyers
1st Year
May 30 @ 12:47PM

Josh Green
1st Year
Mar 29 @ 2:24PM

Doo-Yul Park
1st Year
Jan 30 @ 5:44PM

Kurt MacDonald
3rd Year
Oct 17 @ 11:54PM

Tripp Millican
3rd Year
Oct 4 @ 3:08PM

Andrew Sacher
2nd Year
Jun 28 @ 10:02AM

Julie Dillon
2nd Year
Feb 15 @ 3:50PM

Erik Nelson
1st Year
Feb 2 @ 6:12PM

Herb Yang
1st Year
Dec 13 @ 2:00AM

Mike Brinker
3rd Year
Oct 20 @ 7:38PM

Shelby Wong
1st Year
Mar 18 @ 6:23PM

Ashley York
2nd Year
Mar 2 @ 10:47PM

Stephanie Weinstein
3rd Year
Feb 15 @ 11:43AM

Anita Stokes
1st Year
Nov 12 @ 3:11PM

Michael Lew
Faculty
Oct 7 @ 2:21PM

Fred Stimpson
Faculty
Sep 8 @ 10:20PM

Erik Loyer
Faculty
Mar 21 @ 8:36PM

Julian Bleecker
Faculty

Eddo Stern
Faculty

Jacki Morie
Faculty