« New Video Game Designed To Have No Influence On Kids' Behavior | Main | 511 Reflection »

January 09, 2006

Thoughts from Israel

Over break I visited Israel with my father, middle brother, and uncle December 17th-28th. It was my fifth trip to the country - the last time I was there was December 1997, my sophomore year of high school. Halfway through the trip I jotted down the following thoughts about how to record the experience.

---
My first thought was that I should try to record and report on my trip in the most immersive way possible, because there was no way words could come close to a sufficient description of the places and people I would see. Mark Bolas offered me an audio recorder to bring along, which really intrigued me because sound is such a potent and immersive and inspiring medium. But the more I considered the possibilities the more I shied away from them, finally settling on the same recording methods I used for my undergrad term abroad in London - a simple outline diary of events, and my analog point-and-shoot Pentax camera.

I still stand by the decision, though it puts me at odds with both of my main academic interests. As a student in this department, I have seen the power of media to transport people to another time and place. As a student of history, I know the value of such transportation and the numerous times I have longed for more engaging primary resources in the course of my research. But something even deeper inside me gave me pause and stopped me from covering myself in technology and recording Israel for you.

Israel is an amazing place, unlike anywhere else I have been. Its natural beauty is breathtaking, from the lush forests of the north to the towering desert mountains of the south...I'm just going to stop now. I knew words wouldn't work. Anything I write here is going to sound cliche, like a tourist promotion. Just like any video or audio clips I would have felt comfortable recording. You can't watch Israel from a distance. News reports and travel programs are utterly insufficient, if not misleading. You have to be there. You have to BE Israel. Which is ultimately what kept me from recording. I didn't want to be immortalized as an evesdropper on anyone else, and I didn't want to step out of my own experience to get the intellectual distance necessary to stop experiencing and start recording.

So I'm afraid all I have for you are my thoughts and some photographs, which I am happy to share with you in person over hot chocolate some time. In no way will it come close to an immersive description of Israel. You will just have to go there yourself. And I mean that - it's a trip everyone should make. No matter what your background or opinions or interests, it will be an amazing and rewarding experience. There's no better time than now. (12/24/05)
---

Current events since my return to the US have not changed my sentiments at all. Coming back with a video, saying "Here's what Israel was like just before Sharon became seriously ill" - it would only add to the sense we have here about any foreign country, that it's a place and a time for us to read about in the news or the history books. The world is a place for us to go out and experience as much of as we can. Let's turn off CNN and start buying plane tickets.

Posted by rosenblj at January 9, 2006 01:30 PM

Comments

You know there's something about writing with a pen on paper that will never be eclipsed by newer forms of media. I've kept a journal in some form since I started high school. For quite a while, it has existed in two forms: as a notebook that I write in, and as a Word document on the computer.

I found I was never quite able to stop writing in a paper journal. Writing by hand is a slower process, and I think it allows one to be more reflective; the time it takes forces you to think about what you're writing; to determine how best to say what you're thinking or feeling in as few words as possible. Quite a contrast to the modern Associated Press news article that so obviously relies on Copy-and-Paste functionality.

As for Israel, I would love to hear about your experiences there. It's fascinating that the places where 90% of the Bible took place still exist (in some form anyway)--I'll have to visit someday.

Posted by: msteffen [TypeKey Profile Page] at January 10, 2006 10:39 PM

Thanks for sharing your thoughts on this. My brother and I recently discussed the issue of presence vs recording while on a journey.

I found in Japan I recorded more in various formats than I ever have on all of my previous trips combined, and it was an interesting experience. It was in part due to the fact that this was my first time travelling with my laptop, and having a high-speed internet connection in my main place of residence.

Also, this was my first time travelling alone through a country in which I did not understand the language. This gave me a lot of time to think, reflect, and spend as much time as I wanted to recording my thoughts and experiences. Also, since I stood out whever I went, I felt somehow more free to look as touristy as I needed to - there was no way around it, so I just gave in to it.

Yes, I'm now able to discuss my trip with visuals and audio to support me. Moreso, however, I am very pleased with the recordings I made for myself. Video and pictures will never truly show how beautiful the country side of Japan is, or how it felt to walk around the temples, but when I look at them I am reminded of those feelings, and I think that is important.

And, if you are bored, you can see for yourself the fruits of my labor at http://kelleeinjapan.blogspot.com Maybe it will challenge/support your opinions, depending on what you think of it. Mostly, it was an experiment on travel-logging, so I'm up for feedback!

Posted by: kellee [TypeKey Profile Page] at January 10, 2006 11:49 PM

Jess I appreciate your aesethetic, as Mike said. It does us good to have people taking more time to be in the moment, where they are.

Still, someday I would like to see you experiment with more vivid means of recording. Next time you take a trip, make an audio recording! Make a video! Something -

As you've said, you have a lot of experience with pen and paper, and still cameras. Give yourself a chance to experience other tools, and give us a chance to see through your eyes with them!

I must say, as someone who hopes to have hot chocolate with you, I'm still missing some kind of immersive media experience here - taking only a pen and paper and then saying words can't describe Israel? Write through the cliche! Don't tease me!

I guess there was something about Israel in particular, perhaps the Judeo-Christian religious context, that kept you from wanting to record it in media? Too personal a trip -

Whereas Japan, it somehow invites photography? Accordingly - I've seen many more photos of Japan than I have of Israel! Humph. But maybe that's just me and my media space. I was hoping to visit your Israel MediaSpace Jess!

Posted by: Justin Hall [TypeKey Profile Page] at January 11, 2006 08:32 AM

You are quite astute, Justin. I have not experimented with media recording on other trips, and so have not yet come to grips with how to record without feeling like I'm putting a screen or headphones between me and my environment, cutting me off from my own experience of a place. And you're right, this trip was too personal for me to experiment with. And some of the places I visited were too personal to everyone that I felt it would have been highly inappropriate to treat them as the subject of external scrutiny.

But your challenge has lots of merit. I will try to experiment with recording on trips of less personal emotional weight and see if I can unload some of the intellectual baggage I seem to carry.

And you're right - it is disingenuous of me to say that words can't describe my experience and then offer words as my main artifact. I have two explanations. The first is that I wrote that piece the same way I write poetry - I pick up a pen and the words just come out. If I can't find the right words, the piece dies. And on the eventing of December 24th, I couldn't find the words I wanted to describe my experience. With more reflection, I probably will be able to put my thoughts into writing. The second is that reading the words on the page is what made them sound cliche - in my head they were beautiful and accurate. So maybe I'll just do better at telling you a story about my trip in person. Israel has been a story passed down for thousands of years - if you have the chance to hear it told instead of reading it, it becomes more personal.

Posted by: Jess [TypeKey Profile Page] at January 11, 2006 10:56 AM

Post a comment

Thanks for signing in, . Now you can comment. (sign out)

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)


Remember me?